...Which may, or may not, have "zero relevance" to its consequences in the UK.MrFoolish wrote:So what if it came from Botswana? It has zero relevance to the (suggested) lack of serious consequences in South Africa.
Omicron variant
Forum rules
This is the home for all non-political Coronavirus (Covid-19) discussions on The Lemon Fool
This is the home for all non-political Coronavirus (Covid-19) discussions on The Lemon Fool
-
- The full Lemon
- Posts: 11684
- Joined: November 8th, 2016, 7:21 pm
Re: Omicron variant
-
- Lemon Half
- Posts: 7250
- Joined: November 8th, 2016, 5:56 am
Re: Omicron variant
I see what you did there!XFool wrote:...Which may, or may not, have "zero relevance" to its consequences in the UK.MrFoolish wrote:So what if it came from Botswana? It has zero relevance to the (suggested) lack of serious consequences in South Africa.
-
- The full Lemon
- Posts: 16601
- Joined: November 4th, 2016, 3:58 pm
Re: Omicron variant
In theory perhaps but that doesn't seem to be happening anywhere right now.servodude wrote:In gross terms yes that is greatLootman wrote: Yes but South Africa is also saying that serious illness is down 29% with this variant over the previous one. And that is comparing populations of identical ages.
Now that might be partly due to more of that population having being vaccinated. But then who cares why the rate of serious illness is going down as long as it is going down?
It means that where you would have 1000 severly sick cases for a number of infections you now only have 710 - that is truely a great thing
The problem is that the number of infections we can expect at any one time looks to be about 20 times higher (for current vaccination coverage and social activity)
so where you were dealing with X severely sick cases at any one time you now have (0.71 * X) * 20 or ~14 times as many ( the Gauteng data admissions recorded 18 times)
- it's the incapability to cope with that surge at a practical level that makes this "less severe" variant a big concern
but yes the reduction in severity looks to be very welcome
- we just shouldn't consider that in isolation
And there is a limit to that trend because, if Omicron spreads the way it is claimed, then it will not be that long before everyone who can catch it, will catch it. And at that point it is spent.
So short term keep an eye out, sure. Although if it is really that contagious then the restrictions we adopted in 2020 won't necessarily help a lot. There is a sense that this is a last throw of the dice by the virus. And whilst we may see a temporary increase in illnesses, it will also blow itself out in the process.
Maybe most voters would accept one last deadly hurrah from Covid if we can finally see the light at the end of the tunnel. I cannot see the voters being willing to deal with Covid any more after its second anniversary. Instead they will just take that 2 in 1,000 risk. People are done with this.
-
- Lemon Quarter
- Posts: 1717
- Joined: March 22nd, 2020, 7:27 pm
Re: Omicron variant
Well you tell me how tracing it back to Botswana tells us anything of interest?XFool wrote:...Which may, or may not, have "zero relevance" to its consequences in the UK.MrFoolish wrote:So what if it came from Botswana? It has zero relevance to the (suggested) lack of serious consequences in South Africa.
I can at least tell you that doctors in SA (including the one who made the original report) seem pretty relaxed about Omicron. In a recent interview, she said she thought the UK were over-reacting. She might be wrong, but I suspect she knows more about Omicron than any of us on this board.
-
- The full Lemon
- Posts: 11684
- Joined: November 8th, 2016, 7:21 pm
Re: Omicron variant
That's funny. I could almost swear some people told us 'it' was "spent" in Summer 2020. Some, possibly even earlier...Lootman wrote:In theory perhaps but that doesn't seem to be happening anywhere right now.
And there is a limit to that trend because, if Omicron spreads the way it is claimed, then it will not be that long before everyone who can catch it, will catch it. And at that point it is spent.
Let's keep our fingers and toes crossed and hope that, by Summer 2022, we will actually begin to discern some genuine light at the end of the tunnel.
Last edited by XFool on December 15th, 2021, 10:36 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- The full Lemon
- Posts: 11684
- Joined: November 8th, 2016, 7:21 pm
Re: Omicron variant
She likely knows more than any of us on this board do about Omicron in South Africa.MrFoolish wrote:I can at least tell you that doctors in SA (including the one who made the original report) seem pretty relaxed about Omicron. In a recent interview, she said she thought the UK were over-reacting. She might be wrong, but I suspect she knows more about Omicron than any of us on this board.
-
- The full Lemon
- Posts: 16601
- Joined: November 4th, 2016, 3:58 pm
Re: Omicron variant
There have been people dismissing it prematurely, of course. There have also been people thinking this will never end. I suspect there are even some who don't want this to end because they are perversely enjoying it.XFool wrote:That's funny. I could almost swear some people told us it was "spent" in Summer 2020. Some, possibly even earlier.Lootman wrote:In theory perhaps but that doesn't seem to be happening anywhere right now.
And there is a limit to that trend because, if Omicron spreads the way it is claimed, then it will not be that long before everyone who can catch it, will catch it. And at that point it is spent.
I suspect the truth is someone in the middle. But it also matters what the people will tolerate in terms of further restrictions to their liberty. Luckily our government seems to be aware of this and is taking a measured response.
-
- Lemon Half
- Posts: 7250
- Joined: November 8th, 2016, 5:56 am
Re: Omicron variant
Dear Mr FoolishMrFoolish wrote:Well you tell me how tracing it back to Botswana tells us anything of interest?XFool wrote: ...Which may, or may not, have "zero relevance" to its consequences in the UK.
I can at least tell you that doctors in SA (including the one who made the original report) seem pretty relaxed about Omicron. In a recent interview, she said she thought the UK were over-reacting. She might be wrong, but I suspect she knows more about Omicron than any of us on this board.
First I should thank you for extracting a portion of my post to quote; always a pleasure to see a notifcation
If you can go back a look at it in its entiretly you might notice that I was commenting generally on the fact that comparisons between the UK and Africa have been previously made in this pandemic. The point I was hoping to be understood was that there are significant differences in the demographics that make unadjusted and naive comparisons specious and foolish.
Specifically that the age profile of a population needs careful consideration before attempting to draw any comparison.
As the data for South Africa had already been given in an earlier post I supplied the figures for its neighbour Botswana, from where this variant is thought to originate.
Apologies if this confused, befuddled or aggrieved you
Seasons Greatings
- sd
-
- Lemon Quarter
- Posts: 1717
- Joined: March 22nd, 2020, 7:27 pm
Re: Omicron variant
Indeed, it is hard to argue against a precautionary approach if you look at covid in isolation. I don't stress about wearing a mask in the shops. But I hear from so many people who can't get medical appointments because everything revolves around covid these days. A student I know is suffering from depression because his student life has been pretty much wiped out by restrictions. There is risk either way.Lootman wrote:There have been people dismissing it prematurely, of course. There have also been people thinking this will never end. I suspect there are even some who don't want this to end because they are perversely enjoying it.XFool wrote: That's funny. I could almost swear some people told us it was "spent" in Summer 2020. Some, possibly even earlier.
I suspect the truth is someone in the middle. But it also matters what the people will tolerate in terms of further restrictions to their liberty. Luckily our government seems to be aware of this and is taking a measured response.
-
- Lemon Half
- Posts: 5980
- Joined: November 24th, 2016, 3:29 am
Re: Omicron variant
Your lateral flow test will give you a pretty big clue.XFool wrote:A day or so ago I had very mild symptoms of some chest congestion and coughing. Little more than a passing slight sore throat and, mainly, chesty wheeziness. The sort of thing I'd hardly even bother about normally. Who knows?Hallucigenia wrote:In other news, we're starting to see some lab work on how omicron works. It's very early days but it seems to grow 70x better in bronchus tissue and 10x worse in lung tissue. Nothing in vivo yet, but that would suggest a continuation of how delta got better at transmitting, you get a lot more virus particules in the upper respiratory tract :
https://twitter.com/mugecevik/status/14 ... 6999137281
LFTs give quite a few false negatives but few false positives AIUI, so should you get a positive result, it is probably right.
-
- Lemon Half
- Posts: 5676
- Joined: November 21st, 2016, 4:26 pm
Re: Omicron variant
Is it infectious?XFool wrote: A day or so ago I had very mild symptoms of some chest congestion and coughing. Little more than a passing slight sore throat and, mainly, chesty wheeziness. The sort of thing I'd hardly even bother about normally. Who knows?
-
- Lemon Quarter
- Posts: 1717
- Joined: March 22nd, 2020, 7:27 pm
Re: Omicron variant
I'm happy to see comparisons of where the different demographics might give different outcomes. You mention age. It was mentioned in this thread that 1. SA has a younger population. 2. Omicron seems to pass more through younger people. So wouldn't that make it more of a problem in SA compared to here, not less?servodude wrote:Dear Mr FoolishMrFoolish wrote: Well you tell me how tracing it back to Botswana tells us anything of interest?
I can at least tell you that doctors in SA (including the one who made the original report) seem pretty relaxed about Omicron. In a recent interview, she said she thought the UK were over-reacting. She might be wrong, but I suspect she knows more about Omicron than any of us on this board.
First I should thank you for extracting a portion of my post to quote; always a pleasure to see a notifcation
If you can go back a look at it in its entiretly you might notice that I was commenting generally on the fact that comparisons between the UK and Africa have been previously made in this pandemic. The point I was hoping to be understood was that there are significant differences in the demographics that make unadjusted and naive comparisons specious and foolish.
Specifically that the age profile of a population needs careful consideration before attempting to draw any comparison.
As the data for South Africa had already been given in an earlier post I supplied the figures for its neighbour Botswana, from where this variant is thought to originate.
Apologies if this confused, befuddled or aggrieved you
Seasons Greatings
- sd
-
- Lemon Half
- Posts: 7250
- Joined: November 8th, 2016, 5:56 am
Re: Omicron variant
The spent idea requires lasting immunity - hopefully that happens and hopefully omiron infection helps against delta (and others)XFool wrote:That's funny. I could almost swear some people told us 'it' was "spent" in Summer 2020. Some, possibly even earlier...Lootman wrote:In theory perhaps but that doesn't seem to be happening anywhere right now.
And there is a limit to that trend because, if Omicron spreads the way it is claimed, then it will not be that long before everyone who can catch it, will catch it. And at that point it is spent.
Let's keep our fingers and toes crossed and hope that, by Summer 2022, we will actually begin to discern some genuine light at the end of the tunnel.
The super spreader events I've seen looked at for Omicron do point to it being crazy infectious; so I don't doubt it will get very decent penetration everywhere it lands
The main risk is collateral damage; treatment that cannot be given for other stuff because this consumes too much in the way of health resources
- sd
-
- Lemon Half
- Posts: 7250
- Joined: November 8th, 2016, 5:56 am
Re: Omicron variant
We just don't know yet..MrFoolish wrote: I'm happy to see comparisons of where the different demographics might give different outcomes. You mention age. It was mentioned in this thread that 1. SA has a younger population. 2. Omicron seems to pass more through younger people. So wouldn't that make it more of a problem in SA compared to here, not less?
Young people have a higher social "surface area"
There are proportianally more of them in Africa
Older people are generally prioritised by vaccine programmes
- where's the balance between those contributing factors? we don't know yet
are those the only contributing factors - hell no!
can you choose a contributing factor and point to it as "the reason" - yeah I suppose one could but that's a bit silly
More will become apparent in due course and we'll know where we stand
- or somewhere will accidentally offer up their elderly population as guinea pigs so we can find out
- sd
-
- Lemon Quarter
- Posts: 1717
- Joined: March 22nd, 2020, 7:27 pm
Re: Omicron variant
Top comment on BBC News Have Your Say (seems plausible and genuine):
I am an NHS consultant.
More people are losing their life from inadequate cancer treatment, cardiovascular interventions, delays in thrombolysis for stroke than from what appears (on early analysis) to be a less pathogenic form of Covid.
We mustn’t let this, admittedly terrible pandemic, prevent us for caring for all of those who have treatable conditions and deserve much better.
I am an NHS consultant.
More people are losing their life from inadequate cancer treatment, cardiovascular interventions, delays in thrombolysis for stroke than from what appears (on early analysis) to be a less pathogenic form of Covid.
We mustn’t let this, admittedly terrible pandemic, prevent us for caring for all of those who have treatable conditions and deserve much better.
-
- Lemon Slice
- Posts: 871
- Joined: December 9th, 2016, 6:44 am
Re: Omicron variant
Lots of medically qualified persons think otherwise. Who do you think wrote the standards?Bouleversee wrote:Thanks for the reminder. I'd forgotten that he advised this when all this vaccination started. Makes a lot of sense, unless someone else medically qualified knows better.
What is needed is actual data. An observational study in multiple countries or regions would be worthwhile, you probably don't need to worry much about placebo effects.
-
- Lemon Quarter
- Posts: 3382
- Joined: May 31st, 2019, 7:55 pm
Re: Omicron variant
Better a bungler that at least respects democracy, at least they might try to respect the democratic decision rather than dictate.XFool wrote:Isn't that no more than a further example of the incompetence of those in the Boris Party - i.e. those who brought us Brexit - than anything to do with reality?1nvest wrote:Yesterday they claim a tidal wave of Omicron spread.
Today https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-59640792
-
- Lemon Quarter
- Posts: 2253
- Joined: November 5th, 2016, 3:03 am
Re: Omicron variant
But Gauteng suggests that we could be looking at a 100x increase in cases before that point is reached. So you could be looking at hospitalisations at 71% of 100x the starting point - and the health system will collapse long before that point.Lootman wrote:And there is a limit to that trend because, if Omicron spreads the way it is claimed, then it will not be that long before everyone who can catch it, will catch it. And at that point it is spent.
-
- Lemon Half
- Posts: 7250
- Joined: November 8th, 2016, 5:56 am
Re: Omicron variant
Indeed!MrFoolish wrote:Top comment on BBC News Have Your Say (seems plausible and genuine):
I am an NHS consultant.
More people are losing their life from inadequate cancer treatment, cardiovascular interventions, delays in thrombolysis for stroke than from what appears (on early analysis) to be a less pathogenic form of Covid.
We mustn’t let this, admittedly terrible pandemic, prevent us for caring for all of those who have treatable conditions and deserve much better.
I absolutely agree.
One guaranteed way to prevent folk from being treated is to overrun your hospitals with COVID patients (which seems preferable to choosing to recover treatment from COVID patients?)
- I'll suggest that early action to avoid that would be a good thing - especially for people ill with other things
...and build more capacity/headroom in to the system going forward
-sd
-
- Lemon Half
- Posts: 7250
- Joined: November 8th, 2016, 5:56 am
Re: Omicron variant
I thought we'd covered that already - I'm genuinely not sure where the tricky part isHallucigenia wrote:But Gauteng suggests that we could be looking at a 100x increase in cases before that point is reached. So you could be looking at hospitalisations at 71% of 100x the starting point - and the health system will collapse long before that point.Lootman wrote:And there is a limit to that trend because, if Omicron spreads the way it is claimed, then it will not be that long before everyone who can catch it, will catch it. And at that point it is spent.