Disposal where asset held both outside and in an ISA
Posted: February 13th, 2022, 9:19 pm
I’m just not 100% sure of the position in regard to this matter so all help would be appreciated. Specifically, I am writing about the calculation of a gain or loss when disposing of a stock.
Let’s say I have X no of shares in ABC company in a taxable account (GIA1). I also hold ABC company stock in a second taxable account (GIA2). However, I also hold more shares again in ABC, but this time in an ISA.
If I sell some or all of my ABC shares in GIA1, I will need to calculate the gain or loss arising. I know that, in order to calculate the base cost for my holding in ABC, I must also include the shares in my GIA2 account. However - and this is where my uncertainty lies - do I also need to take account of the shares in my ISA? In other words, must the base cost calculation be based on the cost of ABC shares across all three accounts?
The phrase that sticks in my mind - wherever I heard it - in this regard is ‘the taxman is bound to all that happens in an ISA’ and the key words therein are ‘happens inside’. Is it possible that the above is not something that happens inside the ISA and so a taxpayer cannot ignore the base cost of the ABC shares held inside the ISA when calculating their base cost for the CGT calculation necessitated following the disposal in GIA1.
I hope the above is clear and would welcome all comments and thoughts.
C7
Let’s say I have X no of shares in ABC company in a taxable account (GIA1). I also hold ABC company stock in a second taxable account (GIA2). However, I also hold more shares again in ABC, but this time in an ISA.
If I sell some or all of my ABC shares in GIA1, I will need to calculate the gain or loss arising. I know that, in order to calculate the base cost for my holding in ABC, I must also include the shares in my GIA2 account. However - and this is where my uncertainty lies - do I also need to take account of the shares in my ISA? In other words, must the base cost calculation be based on the cost of ABC shares across all three accounts?
The phrase that sticks in my mind - wherever I heard it - in this regard is ‘the taxman is bound to all that happens in an ISA’ and the key words therein are ‘happens inside’. Is it possible that the above is not something that happens inside the ISA and so a taxpayer cannot ignore the base cost of the ABC shares held inside the ISA when calculating their base cost for the CGT calculation necessitated following the disposal in GIA1.
I hope the above is clear and would welcome all comments and thoughts.
C7