SNAFU - fortunate that it was just a testXFool wrote: Emergency Alert test descends into chaos as it fails to work on up to 10 million phones
![Rolling Eyes :roll:](./images/smilies/icon_rolleyes.gif)
SNAFU - fortunate that it was just a testXFool wrote: Emergency Alert test descends into chaos as it fails to work on up to 10 million phones
SemaphoreMike4 wrote:What happens if the emergency is "All the mobile networks have gone down"?
Semaphore won't work at night though.pje16 wrote:SemaphoreMike4 wrote:What happens if the emergency is "All the mobile networks have gone down"?
at least we know it works
I'll take my grinning face off and post this linkWatis wrote:Semaphore won't work at night though.pje16 wrote: Semaphore
at least we know it works
You'd need to get an Aldis (morse) lamp app for your phone so you can use the flash to signal with.
Watis
My elderly mother was pulled out of school young to work on the family farm shortly after the end of the war. Her father would use semaphore across the fields to tell her which gates to open etc when herding stock. Both also knew Morse code, although I think that was just as a backup for getting weather reports if all else failed. My grandfather went on to be an early CB radio adopter, but the abilities got bred out eventually. I can barely use WhatsApp, although it's easier to carry a phone than have a set of flags on the tractor.pje16 wrote:SemaphoreMike4 wrote:What happens if the emergency is "All the mobile networks have gone down"?
at least we know it works
Dod101 wrote:I do not understand why those who did not receive a signal call it a 'cock up'. The whole idea was to find problems since they have never done this before and then try to iron them out.
Dod
tjh290633 wrote:It woke me up just as Saracens and London Irish had kicked off.
Android 10 on EE, wifi calling.
TJH
From the parallel thread on the Snug, https://www.lemonfool.co.uk/viewtopic.p ... 01#p584701, it appears, anecdotally and unscientifically, that only a small number of folks got a voice read out at all. Most (inc. me) just got the siren and accompanying textual message.stewamax wrote:The brief voice-over on my OnePlus Android 13 phone sounded more New York than New College.
If 'they' had employed a female BBC Newsreader, the test might have been more acceptable. As it was, it resembled a scam phone call.
Or is the voice-over mobile service dependent or phone dependent or did the phone simply text-to-voice read the emergency alert text?
Anyone who followed the link in the alert would have been asked if they would take a survey. The survey covered things like phone model, os version, network etc. Though when I go back in to the alert now, there is no survey prompt.didds wrote: Without that info, then it does become somewhat meaningless - unless the process was to just find out extremely roughly how many people would actually die by not receiving the alert, and whether that is an acceptable level of loss/collateral.
They would be better off spending their time fixing it, so it works properlyelkay wrote: Nobody else has mentioned the survey in any of the threads I have seen, but if even 1% of recipients had completed the survey, they would have a lot of data to work with.
Which in all fairness they need the data to work dopje16 wrote:They would be better off spending their time fixing it, so it works properlyelkay wrote: Nobody else has mentioned the survey in any of the threads I have seen, but if even 1% of recipients had completed the survey, they would have a lot of data to work with.
The info on who DID receive it is useful but not the priority/imperative i would suggest.elkay wrote: Anyone who followed the link in the alert would have been asked if they would take a survey. The survey covered things like phone model, os version, network etc. Though when I go back in to the alert now, there is no survey prompt.
Nothing about please complete a survey. Or an indication that there is a survey even. The overall instruction is generically to not take any action.visit gov.uk/alerts for more information.
This is a test. You do not need to take any action