Space exploitation
-
- Lemon Quarter
- Posts: 1167
- Joined: November 4th, 2016, 1:18 pm
Space exploitation
On this morning's "Start the Week" on R4, the topic was about future commercialisation ideas proposed by messrs Musk and Bezos. As these unfolded I could hadly believe what I was hearing. One of musk's ideas was to set off multiple nuclear explosions on the poles of Mars in order to "warm the planet". When told it would require thousands of such explosions, his response was "No problem."
Astoundingly he has also declared Mars to be an "Open planet".
Apparently the US has already passed a bill proclaiming that while no nation or individual could make claim to a planet, any resources within that planet could be exploited one and all.
Ignoring the fact that the logistics of any such activities are beyond our present capabilities, the arrogance displayed by these men is beyond parody.
Anyone else listen?
Astoundingly he has also declared Mars to be an "Open planet".
Apparently the US has already passed a bill proclaiming that while no nation or individual could make claim to a planet, any resources within that planet could be exploited one and all.
Ignoring the fact that the logistics of any such activities are beyond our present capabilities, the arrogance displayed by these men is beyond parody.
Anyone else listen?
-
- Lemon Quarter
- Posts: 2763
- Joined: November 5th, 2016, 8:43 am
Re: Space exploitation
The atmosphere was once much thicker, thus allowing liquid water to flow. The problem is that the atmosphere today is extremely thin, so there isn't much to 'warm'!Leothebear wrote:On this morning's "Start the Week" on R4, the topic was about future commercialisation ideas proposed by messrs Musk and Bezos. As these unfolded I could hadly believe what I was hearing. One of musk's ideas was to set off multiple nuclear explosions on the poles of Mars in order to "warm the planet". When told it would require thousands of such explosions, his response was "No problem."
Astoundingly he has also declared Mars to be an "Open planet".
Apparently the US has already passed a bill proclaiming that while no nation or individual could make claim to a planet, any resources within that planet could be exploited one and all.
Ignoring the fact that the logistics of any such activities are beyond our present capabilities, the arrogance displayed by these men is beyond parody.
Anyone else listen?
I didn't listen, but I assume that the explosions would not warm the planet directly, but would release a lot of frozen CO2 and water, thus thickening the atmosphere.
Given the radiation reaching the planet, I'm sure that Mars-adapted solar panels could be used to heat the ice, albeit slowly.
Steve
-
- The full Lemon
- Posts: 11684
- Joined: November 8th, 2016, 7:21 pm
Re: Space exploitation
Sadly I missed the beginning of today's Start the Week and only caught the end, which did include some of Musk and his Mars ambitions!Leothebear wrote:Ignoring the fact that the logistics of any such activities are beyond our present capabilities, the arrogance displayed by these men is beyond parody.
Anyone else listen?
They went on to discuss Musk and how he is a strong believer in "Libertarianism", seeing Mars as somewhere off Earth where he and other Libertarians can start over and freely do their own thing without interference by others or government control. One speaker pointed out that Mars is hardly the place for such "freedom" as the only way you could live there is under the most severe control and limitations, due to the obviously highly controlled technical environment required simply to exist.
Returning to the Moon
-
- Lemon Slice
- Posts: 398
- Joined: November 4th, 2016, 10:43 am
Re: Space exploitation
AIUA the simplest way to terraform Mars is to divert ice asteroids to crash into it.
Rob
Rob
-
- Lemon Half
- Posts: 9516
- Joined: November 4th, 2016, 8:17 pm
Re: Space exploitation
Didn't hear any of it, so I can only judge by what's in this thread.XFool wrote:Sadly I missed the beginning of today's Start the Week and only caught the end, which did include some of Musk and his Mars ambitions!Leothebear wrote:Ignoring the fact that the logistics of any such activities are beyond our present capabilities, the arrogance displayed by these men is beyond parody.
Anyone else listen?
That might be eerily close to an idea explored by Ursula LeGuin in The Disposessed. How much does Musk have in common with Odonian ideas?They went on to discuss Musk and how he is a strong believer in "Libertarianism", seeing Mars as somewhere off Earth where he and other Libertarians can start over and freely do their own thing without interference by others or government control. One speaker pointed out that Mars is hardly the place for such "freedom" as the only way you could live there is under the most severe control and limitations, due to the obviously highly controlled technical environment required simply to exist.
-
- Lemon Quarter
- Posts: 2763
- Joined: November 5th, 2016, 8:43 am
Re: Space exploitation
Yes, that another idea I heard of years ago.robbelg wrote:AIUA the simplest way to terraform Mars is to divert ice asteroids to crash into it.
Rob
Though to start with, just about anything gaseous to help make the atmosphere much thicker, CO2 included. Then spread loads of GM moss, lichen etc to start the photosynthesis.
To help the greenhouse effect, maybe some GM farting cows?
Steve
-
- The full Lemon
- Posts: 11684
- Joined: November 8th, 2016, 7:21 pm
Re: Space exploitation
Anyone remember Journey into Space?stevensfo wrote:To help the greenhouse effect, maybe some GM farting cows?
-
- Lemon Quarter
- Posts: 1147
- Joined: November 4th, 2016, 4:10 pm
Re: Space exploitation
Listening to that, I'm just pleased I won't be around. He might be though. I read an article some time ago that he believes in cryogenics. And it will happen.Leothebear wrote:On this morning's "Start the Week" on R4, the topic was about future commercialisation ideas proposed by messrs Musk and Bezos. As these unfolded I could hadly believe what I was hearing. One of musk's ideas was to set off multiple nuclear explosions on the poles of Mars in order to "warm the planet". When told it would require thousands of such explosions, his response was "No problem."
Astoundingly he has also declared Mars to be an "Open planet".
Apparently the US has already passed a bill proclaiming that while no nation or individual could make claim to a planet, any resources within that planet could be exploited one and all.
Ignoring the fact that the logistics of any such activities are beyond our present capabilities, the arrogance displayed by these men is beyond parody.
Anyone else listen?
https://scitechdaily.com/latest-science ... ife-video/
-
- Lemon Half
- Posts: 9757
- Joined: January 22nd, 2017, 2:29 pm
Re: Space exploitation
It's not arrogance it's setting the ground rules as they want them to be.Leothebear wrote:Apparently the US has already passed a bill proclaiming that while no nation or individual could make claim to a planet, any resources within that planet could be exploited one and all.
Ignoring the fact that the logistics of any such activities are beyond our present capabilities, the arrogance displayed by these men is beyond parody.
People with access to extra-terrestrial resources want to establish in terrestrial law their right to exploit those resources.
There is already a contract in place for the sale of lunar dust, with an advance paid, in order to set a precedent.
- https://www.newscientist.com/article/0- ... oon-rocks/BILL NELSON, the administrator of NASA, grinned for the cameras as he handed over a cheque to Justin Cyrus, the boss of a company called Lunar Outpost. The amount? A mere 10 cents. This moment last year was partly a marketing gimmick. But in its own strange way, it was also a legitimately important milestone: it marked the first time that a government agency – or anyone else for that matter – had signed a deal to buy natural resources in space.
If all goes to plan, later this year Lunar Outpost will use a rover to scoop up some lunar dust, snap a photo of it, and officially transfer ownership of the material to NASA. In return, the agency will pay a further fee, this time 90 cents to make a round dollar.
-
- Lemon Quarter
- Posts: 3577
- Joined: November 4th, 2016, 8:43 pm
Re: Space exploitation
Yes - and the spooky sound effect/music at the start.XFool wrote: Anyone remember Journey into Space?
And can you remember the intro to Dick Barton?
(quiz for the over 70s )
-
- Lemon Half
- Posts: 7250
- Joined: November 8th, 2016, 5:56 am
Re: Space exploitation
I think he likes "stuff" a bit too much for life on AnarresUncleEbenezer wrote:Didn't hear any of it, so I can only judge by what's in this thread.XFool wrote: Sadly I missed the beginning of today's Start the Week and only caught the end, which did include some of Musk and his Mars ambitions!That might be eerily close to an idea explored by Ursula LeGuin in The Disposessed. How much does Musk have in common with Odonian ideas?They went on to discuss Musk and how he is a strong believer in "Libertarianism", seeing Mars as somewhere off Earth where he and other Libertarians can start over and freely do their own thing without interference by others or government control. One speaker pointed out that Mars is hardly the place for such "freedom" as the only way you could live there is under the most severe control and limitations, due to the obviously highly controlled technical environment required simply to exist.
-
- Lemon Slice
- Posts: 341
- Joined: January 4th, 2021, 9:28 am
Re: Space exploitation
Isn't the point though that Musk won't be subjected to those rules, just as employees in Twitter have had to sign up for working practices illegal in many countries ( unlimited extra hours witout pay, slave conditions, no right to disagree with authority, no whistle-blowing, discharge without compensation for any infraction of the rules) so the workers on Mars will labour hard to provide Musk with his empire of comfort.XFool wrote:Sadly I missed the beginning of today's Start the Week and only caught the end, which did include some of Musk and his Mars ambitions!Leothebear wrote:Ignoring the fact that the logistics of any such activities are beyond our present capabilities, the arrogance displayed by these men is beyond parody.
Anyone else listen?
They went on to discuss Musk and how he is a strong believer in "Libertarianism", seeing Mars as somewhere off Earth where he and other Libertarians can start over and freely do their own thing without interference by others or government control. One speaker pointed out that Mars is hardly the place for such "freedom" as the only way you could live there is under the most severe control and limitations, due to the obviously highly controlled technical environment required simply to exist.
Returning to the Moon
He simply wants to be the villain in so many sci-fi movies who grates out "Shut off the oxygen" when faced with dissent.
-
- Lemon Quarter
- Posts: 1167
- Joined: November 4th, 2016, 1:18 pm
Re: Space exploitation
The arrogance to which I was refering was Elon Musk's.BobbyD wrote:It's not arrogance it's setting the ground rules as they want them to be.Leothebear wrote:Apparently the US has already passed a bill proclaiming that while no nation or individual could make claim to a planet, any resources within that planet could be exploited one and all.
Ignoring the fact that the logistics of any such activities are beyond our present capabilities, the arrogance displayed by these men is beyond parody.
People with access to extra-terrestrial resources want to establish in terrestrial law their right to exploit those resources.
There is already a contract in place for the sale of lunar dust, with an advance paid, in order to set a precedent.
- https://www.newscientist.com/article/0- ... oon-rocks/BILL NELSON, the administrator of NASA, grinned for the cameras as he handed over a cheque to Justin Cyrus, the boss of a company called Lunar Outpost. The amount? A mere 10 cents. This moment last year was partly a marketing gimmick. But in its own strange way, it was also a legitimately important milestone: it marked the first time that a government agency – or anyone else for that matter – had signed a deal to buy natural resources in space.
If all goes to plan, later this year Lunar Outpost will use a rover to scoop up some lunar dust, snap a photo of it, and officially transfer ownership of the material to NASA. In return, the agency will pay a further fee, this time 90 cents to make a round dollar.
-
- Lemon Half
- Posts: 9757
- Joined: January 22nd, 2017, 2:29 pm
Re: Space exploitation
Sorry, thought that went as read...Leothebear wrote:The arrogance to which I was refering was Elon Musk's.BobbyD wrote: It's not arrogance it's setting the ground rules as they want them to be.
People with access to extra-terrestrial resources want to establish in terrestrial law their right to exploit those resources.
There is already a contract in place for the sale of lunar dust, with an advance paid, in order to set a precedent.
- https://www.newscientist.com/article/0- ... oon-rocks/